When subtraction is replaced by addition of the opposite integer, the opposite of the second term becomes the first term. Commuting subtraction does not produce the same result. Consider the following two examples.
| Example |
Commuting Subtraction |
Adding the Opposite |
| \(9-14\) |
\(14-9 = 5\) |
\((-14)+9 = (-5)\) |
| \(12-5\) |
\(5-12 = (-7)\) |
\((-5)+12=7\) |
Notice the quantities in the second and third columns are not the same. This supports the statement that commuting subtraction is not the same as adding the opposite. Since we know the entries in the third column are correct, it must be the case that subtraction is not commutative.
Next, we note that rewriting \(9-14\) as \((-14)+9\) does not contradict the statement that "subtraction is not commutative" because to do this, we are using the fact that addition is commutative. Below we show the intermediate step:
\[\begin{align*} 9 - 14 &= 9 + (-14) \\ &= (-14) + 9 \end{align*}\]
Here, we use the property of addition being commutative, not subtraction, and therefore no contradiction has been made.